A peach on a dark navy background covered in a grid of small burn dots, with a darker scorched cluster where several dots burned deeper and merged, and smoke rising, under the headline "Every dot is a burn."

A Plasma Pen Treatment Allegedly Left a Patient Permanently Scarred. The Device Is the Problem.

October 26, 2026

By Kate Dee, MD — Founder, MedSpa Board

On October 8, 2026, a Manhattan attorney named Isis Rakia Mattei sued Dream Sculpt Body Spa Inc. in New Rochelle, New York, along with its owner, Dr. Alisa Gladstone-Brown, an anesthesiologist. According to the complaint, filed in Westchester Supreme Court, Mattei received a plasma pen treatment on her forehead and brow on April 8, 2024. She says it left her with permanent pockmark-type indentations, hyperpigmentation, and abnormal skin texture.

She then went through roughly 30 corrective treatments over 50 weeks: red light therapy, radiofrequency microneedling, laser resurfacing, exosomes, and medical-grade skincare. According to the complaint, the damage is still there.

These are allegations. The spa did not respond to a request for comment, and nothing has been proven in court. But the injuries described are exactly what a plasma pen is capable of doing, and they are not rare. My view as a physician is that plasma pens should generally not be offered for cosmetic skin tightening at all, by anyone. That includes physicians.

What the lawsuit claims

Mattei alleges that the spa and its owner failed to properly evaluate whether she was a suitable candidate, failed to use the plasma pen correctly, failed to stop the procedure when signs of excessive thermal injury appeared, and failed to properly diagnose and treat the injury afterward. She also claims lack of informed consent, writing that a reasonably prudent person informed of the risks would not have undergone the procedure.

She is also suing for negligent hiring and supervision, and for product liability. She is seeking to identify everyone at the spa who took part in the procedure and the follow-up treatments, the company that made the pen, and the company representative who trained the spa staff and may have taken part in the procedure itself.

Read that last part again. The person who allegedly trained the staff on a device that burns skin was a sales representative for the company that makes it. That is how a large share of this industry learns to use energy devices. A rep shows up, demonstrates the device on a model, hands out a certificate, and leaves. Device-company training is product training. It is not medical training, and it does not teach anyone to recognize a burn going too deep in real time.

A medical license does not make this device controllable

The defendant here is not an unlicensed operator in a back room. She is a physician who owns the spa. The complaint does not say who held the pen. That is precisely the issue. A medical license on the wall tells a patient who is legally accountable. It does not tell them whether the person in the room can control the device, recognize thermal injury as it happens, or knows when to stop.

With a plasma pen, I would argue that nobody can do that reliably. Here is why.

How a plasma pen works, and why it cannot be made consistent

A plasma pen is a handheld device that creates a small electrical arc in the air between a metal probe tip and the skin. The arc ionizes the gases in the air, which is the “plasma,” and delivers heat to the skin surface. Each contact point is a tiny burn: a carbonized dot of destroyed tissue. Health Canada describes it plainly: these devices cause a controlled burn and spread heat throughout the targeted area.

A typical forehead or eyelid treatment involves hundreds of these dots. Each one is placed by hand. The depth and width of every individual burn depends on how far the tip is held from the skin, how long it hovers, the angle, the power setting, how fast the operator moves, the thickness of the skin at that exact spot, and whether the skin surface is dry or damp. None of that is controlled by the device. All of it depends on the steadiness and judgment of one person’s hand, dot after dot, for the length of the session.

No one can do that perfectly. Not a new esthetician, not an experienced nurse, not a board-certified dermatologist. Hands tire. Patients move. A fraction of a second too long in one spot, or a millimeter too close, and that dot burns deeper than the one next to it. Dots placed too close together merge into a larger wound. Forehead skin over bone, thin eyelid skin, and the skin of the neck all respond differently, and the operator gets no feedback from the device about what is happening beneath the surface.

Compare that to the energy devices legitimate practices use for resurfacing and tightening. A fractional laser delivers its energy through a computer-controlled pattern, with spacing, density, and depth set before the first pulse. Radiofrequency microneedling sets needle depth and energy for each pass. Those devices are not risk-free, and they still depend on proper settings and a trained, licensed operator. But the consistency of each individual point of injury is engineered into the device. With a plasma pen, consistency is left entirely to the human hand.

Even the people selling these treatments admit it. A plasma pen consent form posted online by a practice using one manufacturer’s devices tells the patient that fibroblasting with plasma “is an artistic process - not an exact science.” Burning a patient’s face should not be an art project.

What can go wrong

Health Canada, which first warned the public about plasma pens in 2018 after seizing them from spas, lists the side effects that can occur even when the device is used properly: pain, swelling, redness, sagging skin (particularly in the upper eyelids), hyperpigmentation, ultraviolet sensitivity, and peeling and crusting. When the device is used improperly, the risks include skin punctures from the needle tip, excessive burns from overuse or prolonged use, burns to the eye, and burn complications such as scarring and infection. Health Canada also notes that the likelihood and severity of side effects increase with the duration and frequency of treatment.

In practice, the injuries look like what Mattei describes: pitted, atrophic scars where individual dots burned too deep; patches of dark pigment, which are especially likely in patients with darker skin tones; patches of lost pigment that may never return; and skin texture that no longer looks like the skin around it. Burns near the eye carry their own risks. Once tissue has been destroyed and healed with a scar, there is no treatment that reliably restores it to normal. Corrective treatments can improve the appearance of scarring. They cannot undo it.

This is a lot of risk to take on for a result that is modest at best. The evidence supporting plasma pens for skin tightening is thin, made up largely of small case series and before-and-after photos posted by the people selling the treatment.

The regulatory picture

Plasma pens have a messy regulatory history in the United States. In September 2022, the FDA issued a warning letter to Med Pen Concepts, the maker of the Plasma MD and Plasma + pens. The company was marketing its pens to tighten sagging skin, reduce wrinkles, and serve as a “non-surgical alternative” to eyelid surgery. The FDA found the devices were adulterated and misbranded because they had no premarket approval or clearance. Inspectors also found that the company had changed the power control on its devices, and switched its tips from sterile to non-sterile and to a new manufacturer in a different country, without documenting or validating those changes. The company had received 17 complaints since 2019 and had not recorded or investigated them as federal law requires.

In March 2023, the FDA cleared that same company’s pens through the 510(k) process. The cleared indication is narrow: the removal and destruction of skin lesions and coagulation of tissue. Other plasma pens cleared since then carry similar indications. None of these clearances is for skin tightening, wrinkle reduction, or “non-surgical eyelid lifts.” When a medspa markets a plasma pen for fibroblast skin tightening, that is an off-label use the FDA has not reviewed for safety or effectiveness. Many pens sold online and through training courses have no FDA clearance of any kind.

The FDA has also warned about a different, more powerful plasma device. In 2022, it told providers and consumers not to use the Renuvion/J-Plasma helium plasma system for aesthetic skin resurfacing or skin contraction, after receiving reports of serious adverse events including second- and third-degree burns, infection, changes in skin color, scars, and nerve damage. Different device, same lesson: delivering plasma energy to the skin for cosmetic purposes can cause burns.

Who is doing this, and whether they should be

Plasma pens are aggressively marketed to estheticians and beauty professionals, often through weekend training courses that come with the device. Health Canada specifically called out sales through esthetician training courses. A device that intentionally destroys living tissue is performing a medical procedure. An esthetician license does not cover burning skin. Neither does a cosmetology license, a microblading certificate, or a manufacturer’s course completion certificate.

But the New Rochelle case shows that putting the device in the hands of a physician-owned practice does not solve the problem either. When the device itself cannot deliver consistent results, the only safe answer is not to use it for cosmetic tightening at all.

What legitimate legal compliance looks like

If your practice is still offering plasma pen treatments, stop and ask yourself whether you can defend each of these in front of a regulator or a jury.

Know exactly what device you are using and what it is cleared for. If it has no FDA clearance, it does not belong in a medical practice. If it is cleared only for lesion removal and tissue coagulation, every skin-tightening, wrinkle, and eyelid-lift claim on your website and social media is off-label marketing.

The person holding the device must be licensed to perform a procedure that destroys tissue, and must be working within their scope of practice under the oversight of a medical director. In some states the medical director is a physician; in others, an NP or PA can serve in that role. Either way, that person is responsible for the protocols, the training, and the decision to offer the treatment at all.

Training must be medical training, not a sales demonstration. Your staff should be able to say out loud what excessive thermal injury looks like in the middle of a treatment and exactly when to stop. If they cannot, that is a training gap, and a consent form will not cover it.

Informed consent has to describe the real risks: permanent scarring, permanent pigment changes, and the possibility that corrective treatment will not fix them. A form that calls the treatment an artistic process is not informed consent. It is a disclaimer.

My recommendation is simpler than any of that. Do not offer it. There are better-studied, more controllable options for skin tightening and resurfacing, and patients deserve those instead.

What patients should know

If someone offers you a plasma pen or “fibroblast” treatment for tightening, wrinkles, or a non-surgical eyelid lift, my advice is to decline.

If you are still considering it, ask what device they use and look up whether it is FDA-cleared, and for what. Ask who will be holding the pen. Look up that person’s license. Look up the medical director too. Ask how many of these they have done, and what they will do if something goes wrong. Ask about alternatives, such as fractional laser resurfacing or radiofrequency microneedling performed by a licensed provider.

If you have already had a plasma pen treatment and the dots are not healing, are oozing, are getting deeper, or are leaving dark or white marks, see a board-certified dermatologist or plastic surgeon. Problems with medical devices can be reported to the FDA through MedWatch.

Where MedSpa Board certification fits

Most patients have no way to judge whether a device in a treatment room is safe, cleared, or being used within anyone’s scope of practice. That is the gap The MedSpa Board exists to close. MedSpa Board certified practices are verified for licensing, medical oversight, and the products and devices they use.

If you run a medspa and your standards are ready to be verified, begin your application now. If you want to see where you stand first, download our free checklist that tells you all the requirements to become certified.

— Kate Dee, MD

Sources & further reading

Dr. Kate Dee
Dr. Kate Dee is a Yale-educated physician and founder of the Medspa Board. She is passionate about educating people about the benefits of aesthetics treatments while avoiding the risks and shady practices.
Back to Blog

Medspa Board certification helps licensed med spas stand out by building trust, attracting high-quality clients, and showcasing verified credentials. We help consumers identify top quality medspas that emphasize safety and medical excellence.

CONTACT US

© Copyright 2026. The Medspa Board. All Rights Reserved.